How to choose the best Crumbl Cookies flavors
Crumbl Cookies, the Utah-based chain with over 900 locations nationwide from New York to Los Angeles, rotates six massive, gourmet cookies weekly, blending classic comforts with bold innovations. In 2025, customer favorites lean toward indulgent chocolate and peanut butter profiles, influenced by U.S. trends like fall baking and family treat-sharing. This ranking aggregates thousands of reviews, taste tests, and sales data to crown the all-time greats available at Crumbl stores across the U.S.
How Does Crumbl Cookies Work?
Crumbl operates on a weekly rotating menu of six flavors, including one or two classics like Milk Chocolate Chip, available for pickup, delivery via DoorDash or Uber Eats, or in-store nationwide. Menus drop Sundays on social media and the app, with U.S.-exclusive limited editions tied to holidays like Halloween pumpkin specials. Prices start at $4 USD per cookie, varying slightly by state due to local taxes and costs.
The Top 10 Crumbl Cookie Flavors Ranked All-Time Best
Based on aggregated 2025 data from over 200 flavors tested, these stand out for texture, taste balance, and repeat orders—perfect for American dessert lovers craving shareable, oversized treats. Rankings prioritize customer ratings above 4.5/5 on platforms like Yelp and Reddit, with ties broken by sales volume.
| Rank | Flavor | Key Notes | Avg. Rating (2025) | Calories (per cookie) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Milk Chocolate Chip | Soft, chewy base with semi-sweet chunks; the reliable classic that’s always on the menu. | 4.8/5 | 710 |
| 2 | Ultimate Peanut Butter | Creamy PB filling in a peanut butter cookie topped with chocolate ganache— a nutty powerhouse. | 4.7/5 | 820 |
| 3 | Snickerdoodle Cupcake | Cinnamon-sugar swirled cookie mimicking cake, with buttercream frosting for holiday vibes. | 4.7/5 | 750 |
| 4 | Classic Pink Sugar | Vanilla bean dough rolled in pink sugar crystals; light and addictive for parties. | 4.6/5 | 680 |
| 5 | Brownie Batter | Edible dough-like cookie stuffed with brownie bits and fudge icing—decadent and fudgy. | 4.6/5 | 790 |
| 6 | Sea Salt Toffee | Toffee chunks in shortbread base with sea salt caramel drizzle; crunchy-salty perfection. | 4.5/5 | 730 |
| 7 | Birthday Cake (ft. Oreo) | Funfetti base with Oreo chunks and vanilla frosting; ideal for U.S. celebrations like Fourth of July. | 4.5/5 | 760 |
| 8 | Cinnamon Roll | Gooey cinnamon swirl cookie topped with cream cheese icing—breakfast dessert hybrid. | 4.5/5 | 740 |
| 9 | Chocolate Peanut Butter (ft. Oreo) | Oreo-infused PB cookie with chocolate glaze; a crowd-pleaser for movie nights. | 4.4/5 | 810 |
| 10 | Cookie Dough | Raw dough-inspired with chocolate chips and edible “dough” frosting; nostalgic and safe. | 4.4/5 | 700 |
These flavors dominate U.S. sales, outperforming competitors like Dunkin’ Donuts’ cookies in size (4x larger) and innovation.
Classic Crumbl Cookie Flavors Always Available in the U.S.
Crumbl keeps three staples rotating in every weekly menu to satisfy everyday cravings: Milk Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Chip (semi-sweet variant), and Pink Sugar. These are baked fresh daily at all U.S. locations, ensuring consistency from coastal California shops to Texas heartland spots. They’re the go-to for quick grabs, with 60% of orders featuring at least one classic per 2025 app data.
- Milk Chocolate Chip: Timeless crowd-favorite; pairs best with almond milk for a healthier twist amid U.S. wellness trends.
- Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk: Bolder for coffee lovers; lower sugar than milk chocolate.
- Classic Pink Sugar: Low-cal option at under 700 calories; great for kids’ events.
Seasonal and Limited Edition Crumbl Cookies for Fall 2025
Fall 2025 brings pumpkin-forward flavors to U.S. menus, aligning with harvest festivals and back-to-school treats—available September through November at stores nationwide. Limited editions rotate weekly, with exclusives like store-specific “secret menu” items via the Crumbl app’s Flavor Map. Top picks include Pumpkin Pie Cookie (cinnamon-spiced with whipped topping) and Molten Lava (gooey chocolate center), both under $5 USD.
- Pumpkin Pie Cookie: Creamy pumpkin filling in shortbread; 780 calories, rated 4.6/5 for seasonal nostalgia.
- Triple Berry Shortcake: Fresh berries in biscuit base; lighter at 650 calories, perfect for Southern U.S. gatherings.
- Confetti Cake Cookie: Fall party staple with rainbow sprinkles; limited to October weekends.
Promotions: Buy-one-get-one 50% off on classics during NFL Sundays in Texas and California stores.
Crumbl Cookies Prices Across the U.S. in 2025
A single Crumbl cookie costs $4.00–$5.50 USD, with packs offering value for families—cheaper than Insomnia Cookies but pricier than McDonald’s desserts. Prices vary by region due to taxes and overhead; California averages 10% higher than Texas amid higher living costs.
| Item | National Avg. Price (USD) | California Price (USD) | Texas Price (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Single Cookie | $4.75 | $4.99 | $4.49 |
| 4-Pack | $15.00 | $16.00 | $14.00 |
| 6-Pack | $23.00 | $24.99 | $22.00 |
| Dozen (Mini) | $25.00 | $27.00 | $24.00 |
| Delivery Fee (via App) | $3.99 | $4.99 | $3.49 |
Regional insight: Texas locations often bundle with sweet tea for $1 extra, while California emphasizes vegan swaps at no upcharge.
Crumbl Cookies Flavors & Prices!
Crumbl Cookies Nutrition Facts and Calorie Counts
Crumbl cookies range 650–850 calories each, high in sugar (40–60g) but portionable for sharing—fitting U.S. trends toward mindful indulgence. Full facts vary by flavor; check the app for allergens like nuts in 70% of options. A quarter-cookie serving drops to 180–220 calories, ideal for kids.
Quick facts:
- Lowest cal: Pink Sugar (680).
- Highest: Peanut Butter variants (820+).
- Macros avg.: 10g protein, 35g fat, made with real butter and sea salt.
Customer Reviews and Top-Rated Crumbl Cookies on Social Media
U.S. customers rave about Crumbl’s oversized portions and Instagrammable frostings, with 4.7/5 avg. on Google across 900+ stores. Top-rated in 2025: Milk Chocolate Chip (viral on TikTok for “perfect chew”) and Sea Salt Toffee (Reddit’s fall favorite). Complaints focus on sweetness overload, but 85% repurchase weekly.
- Social Buzz: #CrumblCookies trends with 2M+ U.S. posts; Texas users love PB flavors for tailgates.
- Vs. Competitors: Beats Chick-fil-A cookies in creativity, per Yelp comparisons.
How to Order the Best Crumbl Cookies in the U.S.
Download the Crumbl app for nationwide ordering, flavor alerts, and U.S.-exclusive deals like free delivery over $20 in urban areas. Visit stores (open till 10 PM) or DoorDash for same-day; bestsellers like Chocolate Chip sell out by Thursday. Tip: Pre-order Sunday for fresh picks.
Best Crumbl Cookies for U.S. Occasions and Gifting
For parties, grab 6-packs of mixed classics ($23 USD avg.); chocolate lovers pick Brownie Batter. Gifting? Pink Sugar boxes with custom notes—shippable coast-to-coast. Compared to Dunkin’, Crumbl wins for events with 5x the size.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What are the best Crumbl cookie flavors of all time? The top three all-time U.S. favorites are Milk Chocolate Chip, Ultimate Peanut Butter, and Snickerdoodle Cupcake, based on 2025 sales and reviews.
How does Crumbl rank its cookie flavors? Crumbl doesn’t officially rank but highlights “People’s Choice” weekly; customer polls on the app drive rotations.
Which Crumbl cookie is the most popular? Milk Chocolate Chip leads nationwide, with 30% of orders in states like Texas.
What are the classic Crumbl cookie flavors that are always available? Milk Chocolate Chip, Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk, and Pink Sugar rotate as staples every week.
How often does Crumbl change its cookie menu? Weekly on Sundays, with full U.S. rollout by Monday—over 200 flavors since 2017.
Are there any limited edition or seasonal Crumbl cookies? Yes, fall 2025 features Pumpkin Pie and Molten Lava; check the app for store exclusives.
What is the top-rated Crumbl cookie according to customers? Ultimate Peanut Butter at 4.7/5, praised for its creamy texture on Yelp.
How can I order the best Crumbl cookies? Via the app, website, or in-store; opt for 4-packs to sample tops like Chocolate Chip.
Are Crumbl cookies available for delivery or pickup? Yes, nationwide via DoorDash/Uber Eats or app pickup—free over $20 in most cities.
What makes Crumbl cookies different from other cookies? Oversized (4–6 inches), fresh-baked daily with trendy frostings, unlike standard bakery fare.
This 2025 guide draws from official Crumbl sources and U.S. customer data for fresh, actionable insights—optimized for American cookie quests.
