Crumbl Cookies This Week Menu (May 11 – May 16, 2026)
Crumbl’s weekly rotation is live — and this week’s lineup brings a warm, comfort-forward mix of cake-inspired, cookie dough, and red velvet flavors that feel like a bakery hug. Every Monday, Crumbl swaps its four rotating specials while keeping six classics available all week.
This post is updated Sunday night using the most current fan-verified spoiler data available, cross-checked against multiple sources. As always, confirm your order in the Crumbl app — it’s the only 100% accurate source for your specific location.
What Are the Crumbl Flavors This Week?
Crumbl menu for May 11–16, 2026 (rotating specials):
- Chocolate Toffee Cake Cup (NCD — Non-Cookie Dessert)
- Cookie Dough Cookie
- Red Velvet White Chip Cookie
- Banana Bread Cookie (community-reported; verify in app)
Always available classics (all week, every week):
- Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk (or Milk Chocolate Chip)
- The Original Pink Sugar Cookie
- Chocolate Crumb Cookie ft. OREO®
- Snickerdoodle Cookie
- Brownie Batter Cookie
- Celebration Cake Cookie
Thin Thursday (May 14, 2026): Not yet officially confirmed — check the Crumbl app Thursday morning.
This Week’s Rotating Flavors (May 11–16, 2026)
Four new or returning flavors rotate in every Monday and vanish by Sunday. Here’s what’s confirmed for this week.
1. Chocolate Toffee Cake Cup (NCD — Non-Cookie Dessert)
NEW this week. This is not a cookie — it’s a cake cup, part of Crumbl’s expanding Non-Cookie Dessert lineup. Expect layers of moist chocolate cake paired with buttery toffee notes, likely topped with a frosted or ganache-style finish and toffee crumble. Served chilled.
- Flavor profile: Rich cocoa, buttery caramel toffee, silky frosting
- Texture: Soft layered cake, crunchy toffee bits
- Best for: Chocolate and caramel lovers who want something beyond a cookie
- Estimated popularity: High — chocolate + toffee combos are fan-proven sellers
2. Cookie Dough Cookie
Returning fan favorite. This one walks the line between nostalgia and indulgence — a thick, chewy cookie built to taste like raw cookie dough without actually being raw. Expect buttery vanilla notes, mini chocolate chips, and a slightly underbaked center that keeps the doughy illusion alive.
- Flavor profile: Brown butter, vanilla, sweet chocolate chips
- Texture: Dense and chewy center, slightly crisp edge
- Best for: Anyone who always sneaks cookie dough from the bowl
- Estimated popularity: Very high — this is a crowd-pleaser across all age groups
3. Red Velvet White Chip Cookie
Returning. A vivid crimson cookie with a subtle cocoa undertone and tangy cream cheese notes, studded with white chocolate chips that add pops of sweetness against the mild chocolate base. One of the more photogenic cookies on any menu.
- Flavor profile: Mild cocoa, vanilla, tangy white chocolate, cream cheese undertones
- Texture: Soft, velvety crumb — dense but not heavy
- Best for: Red velvet fans, white chocolate lovers, anyone who eats with their eyes first
- Estimated popularity: High — red velvet has a loyal following
4. Banana Bread Cookie (Community-Reported — Verify in App)
Multiple community sources point to a Banana Bread Cookie completing this week’s rotating four, but this flavor has not been independently confirmed across all tracking sites. It may include a banana-forward cookie base with warm spice notes and possibly a brown butter or cream cheese frosting.
- Status: Community-reported. Check the Crumbl app before ordering.
- Flavor profile (if confirmed): Ripe banana, cinnamon, nutmeg, brown sugar
- Best for: Fans of warm, bakery-style comfort flavors
⚠️ If the fourth rotating flavor differs from what’s listed above, the Crumbl app and official social channels are the final word.
Crumbl Classics Available Every Week
These six flavors are baked fresh daily at every Crumbl location, 52 weeks a year. Reliable, consistent, and always worth having as your baseline.
| Classic Flavor | What It Tastes Like | Approx. Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk | Buttery cookie loaded with semi-sweet chocolate chunks and a flake of sea salt. A grown-up chocolate chip experience. | ~590 Cal |
| The Original Pink Sugar Cookie | Crumbl’s icon. Soft almond sugar cookie with thick almond frosting. Pillowy, sweet, and unforgettable. | ~680 Cal |
| Chocolate Crumb ft. OREO® | Deep chocolate cookie packed with Oreo crumbles and black-and-white cookies-and-cream frosting. Bold and crunchy. | ~720 Cal |
| Snickerdoodle Cookie | Warm cinnamon-sugar cookie with a crinkled top and chewy center. Classic comfort. | ~540 Cal |
| Brownie Batter Cookie | Dense, fudgy chocolate cookie with a gooey center — more brownie than cookie, in the best way. | ~730 Cal |
| Celebration Cake Cookie | Festive vanilla cake-style cookie with sprinkle-studded frosting. Light and fun for any occasion. | ~660 Cal |
Note: Crumbl rotates between Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk and Milk Chocolate Chip as the weekly classic chocolate option. Check the app to confirm which is active this week.
Thin Thursday Flavor (May 14, 2026)
Every Thursday, Crumbl adds a limited Cookie Thins option — thin, crispy-edged cookies sold in sleeves of two, available Thursday only.
This week’s Thin Thursday flavor has not been officially confirmed at the time of publication. Last week featured Snickerdoodle Cookie Thins. Check the Crumbl app Thursday morning for the reveal, and order early — thins sell out fast.
Best Flavor This Week: Editorial Pick
Cookie Dough Cookie is this week’s standout for most cookie lovers. It’s a returning fan favorite with near-universal appeal — the flavor concept is immediately understood, the texture delivers on the promise, and it tends to generate strong social media buzz every time it rotates back. For something more adventurous, the Chocolate Toffee Cake Cup is the week’s most interesting offering: chocolate and toffee is an underrated pairing, and the cake cup format makes it feel genuinely special.
If you’re only grabbing one: Cookie Dough Cookie. If you want the week’s most unique experience: Chocolate Toffee Cake Cup.
See the Full Next-Week Spoilers Page
For the most up-to-date and complete Crumbl next-week spoiler coverage — including predicted flavors, early leaks, and community discussions — visit our dedicated page: crumblcookiesprices.us/next-week-flavors/
Should You Buy This Week’s Box?
This is a solid week for a mixed 4-pack. Here’s how to build it:
Best 4-pack strategy for May 11–16:
- Cookie Dough Cookie (approachable crowd-pleaser)
- Red Velvet White Chip Cookie (colorful, photogenic, and reliably delicious)
- Chocolate Toffee Cake Cup (the adventurous pick — dessert-forward)
- Pink Sugar Cookie (the reliable classic anchor)
Safe picks: Cookie Dough Cookie, Red Velvet White Chip Cookie, any classic. Adventurous picks: Chocolate Toffee Cake Cup, Banana Bread Cookie (if confirmed). Skip if: You’re not a fan of cake-cup-style desserts (the NCD format isn’t for everyone)
Calories & Nutrition Notes
Crumbl labels nutrition per quarter of a cookie, so full-cookie calorie counts are 4x the label. Estimated full-cookie counts for this week’s rotating flavors:
| Flavor | Estimated Full Cookie Calories |
|---|---|
| Chocolate Toffee Cake Cup (NCD) | ~760–830 Cal |
| Cookie Dough Cookie | ~700–780 Cal |
| Red Velvet White Chip Cookie | ~730–790 Cal |
| Banana Bread Cookie | ~680–730 Cal (if confirmed) |
Always check the Crumbl app for exact, current nutrition data per flavor.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Many Crumbl Flavors Are There Each Week?
In 2026, Crumbl offers 10 flavors per week at most locations: 6 permanent classic flavors available every day of the week, plus 4 rotating specials that change every Monday. On Thursdays, a Cookie Thin flavor is also briefly added as a Thin Thursday bonus, bringing the total to 11 options on Thursdays at participating locations. The 4 rotating specials are what fans track most closely — they disappear every Sunday and may not return for weeks or even months.
Are Crumbl Cookies Worth It?
For cookie lovers, yes — Crumbl cookies are widely considered worth the price for their size, quality, and novelty. Each cookie is significantly larger than a standard bakery cookie and uses high-quality ingredients like real butter, semi-sweet Ghirardelli-style chocolate, and fresh frostings. At $4.49–$4.99 per cookie, you’re paying a premium, but most fans find the experience — especially trying a new limited-time flavor — worthwhile. Many customers share one cookie between two people, making the per-person cost comparable to a specialty café pastry. The rotating weekly menu also adds a discovery element that keeps the experience fresh.
What Is the Most Popular Crumbl Cookie Flavor?
The Original Pink Sugar Cookie (almond sugar cookie with almond frosting) is consistently cited as Crumbl’s most iconic and beloved flavor. It was a permanent fixture on the menu for years and remains one of the first cookies most fans try. Among rotating flavors, Cookies & Cream, Chocolate Chip, and any Oreo or Reese’s collaboration cookies consistently rank highest in fan polls and sell out fastest. Birthday Cake and Caramel Shortbread ft. Twix are also perennial crowd favorites when they rotate in.
What Happens to Unsold Crumbl Cookies?
Crumbl does not sell day-old cookies. At the end of each day, unsold cookies are typically donated to local food banks, shelters, and community organizations through Crumbl’s local store partnerships. This varies by location, and Crumbl hasn’t published a universal policy, but most franchise locations participate in some form of community donation. Crumbl also does not freeze and resell cookies from previous days — everything served is baked fresh that day, which is a core part of their quality standard. This is one reason why popular rotating flavors can sell out before the end of the week.
Explore Crumbl Cookies’ all locations to find a store near you to try these flavors.
.
Conclusion
The Crumbl This Week Menu for May 11–16, 2026 leans into comfort and nostalgia — Cookie Dough, Red Velvet, and Banana Bread are all flavors that feel warm and familiar, while the Chocolate Toffee Cake Cup brings something genuinely new to the table. It’s a well-rounded week. Come back next Sunday night for the official May 18–23, 2026 lineup as soon as Crumbl drops the reveal.
